James Davis McCotter, 79 of Valparaiso, IN, passed away peacefully on January 6, 2025. He was born November 26, 1945, in Chicago, IL, to the late Dorian and Eva (Hammond) McCotter. Jim graduated from Fenger High School in Chicago, and went on to proudly serve in the United States Navy as an Electrician’s Mate. Jim traveled the world on the USS Sandoval and served in the Vietnam War. After briefly working for the railroad, Jim began a career with the Ford Motor Company Stamping Plant in Chicago Heights, IL, as an Electrician, and retired after 34 years as a Superintendent. Following his retirement, Jim took up a part time job delivering medication for the Fagen Pharmacy in Valparaiso, which allowed him to meet many lovely people.
Growing up, Jim was very active in Boy Scouts and even earned the rank of Star. In his younger years, Jim enjoyed playing softball and specialized as the catcher, which earned him the nickname “Jimmy the Catcher”. He also played in bowling leagues, loved to dance, and play his music loud. Jim was raised as a Presbyterian, but after meeting his wife, became a member of St. Paul Catholic Church. Jim loved animals and over the years gave many pets a loving home. He was a tenderhearted and selfless man with a great sense of humor and quick wit. Though known for his quiet and softspoken nature, you would often be met with a “Howdy” when Jim greeted you. He was a loving and devoted family man, who worked hard to provide for his wife and children. Jim will be deeply missed by all who knew him.
On May 12, 1973, in Chicago, Jim married the love of his life, Cheryl Brazzale, who survives, along with their children: Brandi Lee (Thomas) Foreman of Valparaiso, Eric J. McCotter of Philadelphia, PA, Raven (Dave) Foreman of Wanatah, Ashley (Wesley) Kozuszek of Porter; grandchildren: Remington, Liam, Dylanger, Londyn, Finley, Wyley, and Hailey; and lifelong best friend, Gerry Silver. He was preceded in death by his sister, Carol McCotter; and his boxer, Harper.
A Celebration of Jim’s life will be announced at a later date. He will be laid to rest privately at Angelcrest Cemetery.
GUESTBOOK
Praying for you and your family Cher. So very sorry for your loss. -Cheryl Battisti
My prayers and thoughts are with you and your family. -Cheryl Watson
Jim was a great man, RIP Jim. Prayers for Cheryl ,Dave ,Rave, Brandi ,Tom, Wes and Ashley. -Jamie Greenlee
Cheryl, My sincerest condolences for your present loss of Jim. Though it's been years, I have very fond memories of the two of you as Lor and I were young girls popping in and out of her sister and her husband's lives. I always viewed the two of you as such a great couple, extremely in tune with each other and having the type of relationship to strive for. Though I know you will miss him dearly, I know your strong faith will carry you through. You two have built a wonderful family and his legacy will continue in your children and grandchildren. My prayers, I offer for your comfort and assurance that you will meet again. With great fondness, -Kathy Johnston Ragin
Your whole family is in our thoughts and prayers. We pray for comfort and peace that passes all understanding for your family. May the joy of the Lord be with you knowing that Jim is with Jesus now and has no more pain. We always remember Jim's humor and I can picture him laughing and telling a joke to Jesus. We'll keep you in our prayers for peace and comfort, love -Norm & Sharon Smith
To Cheryl, Brandi, Eric, Raven, & Ashley as well as the rest of the family, you are in our prayers and our hearts. I know your dad/husband is in Heaven with Jesus and your family, as well as my mom and dad, and they are all looking down on all of you; being your guardian angels. We are here for you if you need anything at all! Love you, -The Delgado’s Ernie, Cathy, Michael & Meagan. Matthew 5:4 Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted.
