David “Dave” Michael Sutton, 53 of Plymouth, passed away on Thursday, August 10, 2023. He was born on July 4, 1970 in Valparaiso, IN to Robert F. and Suzanne M. (Simmons) Sutton. He graduated from Knox High School and made his career in woodworking for many years. Dave enjoyed his work, from owning a lumber company to fabrication and carpentry, he did it all. He took pride in making old things new again. Making people laugh was his greatest talent. He loved to fish, restore things, and above all, spend time with his family and friends.    
On October 23, 2010 in New Hope, PA, David married the love of his life, Erica Nemeth-Sutton, who survives, along with children: Megan Justine Sutton, Jared Michael Sutton, and Grace Elizabeth Sutton; sister, Melissa (Curtis) McIntire; nephew, Aiden McIntire; niece, Addison McIntire; and was a father-figure for Jacob Schrock. He is preceded in death by his parents, Robert and Suzanne.
A visitation will be held on Sunday, August 13, 2023 from 12:00 – 3:00 PM with a service beginning at 3:00 PM at Moeller Funeral Home, 104 Roosevelt Rd., Valparaiso, Indiana. A private burial will take place at Angelcrest Cemetery. Memorial donations may be made to AA.


Jared, Thoughts and prayers are with you and the Sutton family. Praying you will feel the love of God surround you. -Dorene Miller 

I'm so sorry for your loss. Dave was acgreat guy, funny and always had a smile of his face when we were in school. He was a great member of the class of 88. God be with you all. -Kristina Wallen Horn 

So sad about this. I have great memories of David. -Rebecca Patterson 

My deepest sympathies to all of the Sutton family, you will remain in my thoughts and prayers in the difficult days ahead. Prayers for courage, comfort and the peace of God that surpasses all understanding. I know that dave has left treasured memories that will remain in the hearts of all who loved him. Let these memories bring solace to you in the days ahead slowly replacing the deep sorrow of today. Love to you all. -Bridget Siddall

Erica and family Please know that we are keeping you in prayer during this difficult time. If we can be of any help don't hesitate to ask. -Anita's parents, Gary and Beverly Earnhart 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email